top of page
Search

IRS and California Underpayment Penalty Relief How to Qualify for Abatement

Writer: Chris Torres
Chris Torres
Nov 6
8 min read

A tax notice can feel frustrating, especially when the balance comes from a penalty you did not expect. Underpayment penalties are common for taxpayers who did not pay enough tax during the year, even if they paid the full balance by the tax filing deadline.


The IRS and the California Franchise Tax Board both expect taxpayers to pay tax throughout the year. For many people, that happens through paycheck withholding. For business owners, investors, retirees, landlords, and self-employed taxpayers, it often happens through estimated tax payments.


If not enough tax is paid in as the year goes on, the IRS or FTB may assess an underpayment penalty. The final estimated tax payment for a calendar-year taxpayer is generally due January 15 for the previous tax year, unless the date falls on a weekend or legal holiday.


The good news is that a notice does not always mean the penalty is final. In some cases, taxpayers may qualify for penalty abatement, which means the IRS or FTB removes or reduces the penalty after reviewing the facts.


This article explains how underpayment penalties work, when relief may be available, and why it is worth having a tax professional review the notice before paying it without question.


Close-up view of a tax notice beside a household calendar
A tax notice is often the first sign that estimated payments need a closer look.

What an underpayment penalty means


An underpayment penalty is assessed when a taxpayer does not pay enough tax during the year. This can happen even when the tax return is filed on time.


The IRS and California do not want taxpayers to wait until April to pay the whole year’s tax bill. Instead, tax is supposed to be paid as income is earned. That is why employees have withholding taken out of each paycheck. It is also why estimated tax payments exist.


Common situations that lead to underpayment penalties include:


  • Self-employment income with little or no estimated tax paid

  • Capital gains from selling stock, real estate, cryptocurrency, or a business asset

  • Retirement income without enough withholding

  • Rental income that creates taxable profit

  • A large bonus with insufficient withholding

  • A spouse starting a business or changing jobs

  • Reduced withholding after updating Form W-4

  • Income that increased sharply compared with the prior year


The penalty is not the same as the tax itself. The tax is the amount owed based on income, deductions, credits, and other items on the return. The penalty is an extra charge for paying too little during the year.


For example, someone may file a return showing that the correct tax was $30,000. If only $20,000 was paid through withholding and estimated payments, the taxpayer may owe the remaining $10,000 plus an underpayment penalty.


The IRS and FTB calculate these penalties under their own rules. The amounts may differ, and each agency sends its own notice.


Why taxpayers receive IRS or California FTB notices


A notice usually means the IRS or FTB believes the taxpayer did not meet one of the payment requirements for the year. The notice may arrive after the return is processed, or it may show up when an adjustment changes the tax due.


Notices can be triggered by many issues, such as:


  • Estimated tax payments posted to the wrong year

  • Missing or misapplied payments

  • Income reported on tax forms that was not fully paid in during the year

  • A return showing a balance due larger than expected

  • A state calculation that differs from the federal calculation

  • A late or skipped estimated tax payment


A notice is not always correct. Payments can be misapplied. A taxpayer may have made estimated payments under the wrong Social Security number, business name, tax year, or spouse. A state payment may have been made, while the federal payment was missed, or the reverse may be true.


That is why the first step is not always to pay immediately. The first step is to review the notice carefully and compare it to the tax return, payment records, bank statements, and estimated tax vouchers.


A notice should be checked for:


  • The tax year involved

  • The amount of penalty assessed

  • The agency issuing the notice

  • The response deadline

  • Whether the notice includes tax, penalty, interest, or all three

  • Whether the agency credited all payments correctly


If the notice is correct, relief may still be available. If the notice is wrong, a response may be needed to correct the account.


When underpayment penalties may be removed or reduced


Not every underpayment penalty qualifies for relief. The IRS and California generally expect taxpayers to make timely payments during the year. Still, the law allows penalty relief in certain situations.


Relief often depends on the reason for the underpayment and the quality of the supporting documentation. The agency will look for facts showing that the taxpayer had a valid reason and acted responsibly under the circumstances.


Possible reasons for relief may include:


  • A serious illness or medical issue

  • Death or serious illness of an immediate family member

  • A natural disaster or casualty loss

  • Retirement or disability, when specific requirements are met

  • Unusual circumstances that made timely payment difficult

  • A payment processing issue outside the taxpayer’s control

  • Income received unevenly during the year

  • An agency error or payment misapplication


The key is showing more than “I did not know” or “I forgot.” Tax agencies usually want a clear explanation supported by records.


For example, a taxpayer who sold investment property late in the year may have most of the income concentrated in the fourth quarter. If the penalty was calculated as though the income arrived evenly all year, a different method may reduce the penalty.


In other cases, the penalty may be based on a missing payment that was actually made. A bank statement, payment confirmation, or canceled check may help resolve the issue.


The annualized income method may help


Some taxpayers earn income unevenly. This is common for real estate professionals, consultants, contractors, business owners, investors, and taxpayers who receive large year-end payments.


The standard penalty calculation often assumes income was earned evenly throughout the year. When that is not true, the annualized income method may produce a better result.


This method looks at when income was actually earned and when payments were made. It can reduce or remove a penalty if the taxpayer paid enough based on income received during each period.


This can be especially helpful when income arrived late in the year, such as:


  • A large capital gain in November or December

  • A year-end bonus

  • A business payment received in the fourth quarter

  • A sale of property near the end of the year

  • Seasonal business income


The annualized method takes more work, but it can be worth reviewing if the penalty is significant.


A waiver request may apply in limited cases


For federal taxes, taxpayers may request a waiver of certain estimated tax penalties when specific circumstances apply. This often involves explaining the facts and attaching supporting documents.


California also has procedures for requesting relief from certain penalties. The FTB may review whether the taxpayer had reasonable cause or qualifies under rules that apply to the specific penalty type.


The forms and standards are not identical between the IRS and California. A penalty removed by one agency is not automatically removed by the other. Each notice should be reviewed separately.


Eye-level view of receipts and payment confirmations sorted on a kitchen table
Good records make it easier to challenge or reduce a penalty.

What the IRS and FTB look for in a relief request


A strong penalty relief request tells a clear story. It does not need to be dramatic. It needs to be organized, accurate, and backed by records.


A typical review may include:


  • The tax return for the year in question

  • IRS or FTB notices

  • Proof of estimated tax payments

  • Payroll withholding records

  • Bank statements showing payments

  • Medical records, disaster documents, or other support if relevant

  • Prior-year tax information

  • Income timing details for uneven income


The explanation should connect the facts to the requested relief. If the issue was a serious illness, the request should explain how the illness affected the ability to make timely payments. If the issue was a late-year capital gain, the request should show when the gain occurred and how payments were made after that point.


A well-prepared request usually answers three questions:


  1. What caused the underpayment?

  2. What did the taxpayer do to comply once the issue became known?

  3. Why should the penalty be removed or reduced under the applicable rules?


It also helps to be realistic. Tax agencies may deny relief if the explanation is vague, unsupported, or based only on inconvenience. They may also deny relief if the taxpayer repeatedly failed to pay estimated taxes without a clear reason.


That does not mean relief is impossible. It means the request should be prepared carefully.


Why California taxpayers should review both federal and state penalties


California taxpayers often have to deal with two separate tax agencies: the IRS and the California Franchise Tax Board. A federal notice and a California notice may involve similar facts, but they are not the same case.


The IRS applies federal rules. The FTB applies California rules. Each agency has its own forms, deadlines, notices, and review process.


This matters because a taxpayer may qualify for relief with one agency but not the other. It is also possible that one agency has credited payments correctly while the other has not.


For example:


  • A taxpayer may have made federal estimated payments but missed California payments.

  • A California payment may have been applied to the wrong tax year.

  • Withholding may have covered federal tax but not enough California tax.

  • A federal return may show a smaller balance due than the California return because of state-specific adjustments.


For Orange County taxpayers and California residents, state penalties can be a major part of the total balance. Ignoring the FTB notice while addressing the IRS notice can lead to additional collection letters, interest, or account issues.


Both notices deserve attention.


Steps to take after receiving an underpayment penalty notice


A penalty notice should not sit unopened. Deadlines matter, and waiting too long may limit options.


Start with these steps:


Read the notice from top to bottom


Look for the tax year, amount due, response date, and explanation. Check whether the notice came from the IRS or the FTB.


Compare the notice to your records


Review your tax return, estimated tax payments, withholding, and bank records. Confirm that all payments were posted correctly.


Identify the reason for the penalty


Was the issue caused by missed estimated payments, uneven income, a large capital gain, reduced withholding, or a payment error? The reason affects the best response.


Do not assume the penalty is final


Some penalties can be corrected, reduced, or removed. A professional review can help determine whether a relief request is worth pursuing.


Respond before the deadline


If a response is needed, send it on time. Keep copies of everything submitted, including proof of mailing or electronic confirmation.


How OC Tax CPA can help


Underpayment penalties can be confusing because the answer is not always obvious from the notice. The IRS or FTB may calculate a penalty automatically, but that calculation may not reflect the full story.


OC Tax CPA helps taxpayers review IRS and California notices, identify possible relief options, and prepare responses when removal or reduction may be available.


That may include:


  • Reviewing IRS and FTB penalty notices

  • Checking whether payments were applied correctly

  • Evaluating whether a waiver or abatement request may apply

  • Reviewing uneven income and estimated tax payment timing

  • Preparing a response to the IRS or California FTB

  • Helping plan estimated tax payments for the current year


If you received a notice for an underpayment penalty, do not assume you have no options. Contact OC Tax CPA to review the notice and see whether you may qualify to have the penalty removed or reduced.


This article is for general informational purposes only and is not tax or legal advice. Tax penalty relief depends on the facts, the tax year, the agency involved, and the documentation available.


The takeaway for underpayment penalty relief


Underpayment penalties are assessed when the IRS or California Franchise Tax Board believes not enough tax was paid throughout the year. The final estimated tax payment for the prior year is generally due January 15 for calendar-year taxpayers, but penalties can still arise when earlier payments were missed or too low.


A notice does not always mean the penalty is correct, and it does not always mean relief is impossible. Payment errors, uneven income, unusual circumstances, and qualifying hardship situations may support a request for removal or reduction.


The best next step is simple: review the notice before paying it, gather your records, and get professional help if the penalty is significant or the facts are not clear. At OC Tax CPA, we are here to help taxpayers with IRS and California penalty relief and determine whether an abatement request may be available.


 
 
 

Comments


OC Tax CPA​

​

Office Address: 1 Park Plaza Suite 600 Irvine, CA 92614

Flag_of_the_United_States.svg.png

Call The Office

Office Hours

Mon - Sat 8am - 6pm

Sun: CLOSED

SERVICES

Tax Planning

Tax Preparation

Bookkeeping

Financial Statement Compilation

Payroll & Business Services

Business Formation

​

​

HELPFUL LINKS

bottom of page