top of page
Search

How to Avoid IRS and California FTB Estimated Tax Penalties and What to Do If Youve Been Assessed

Writer: Chris Torres
Chris Torres
Nov 6
17 min read

Estimated tax penalties are common because the rules are not intuitive. The IRS and California Franchise Tax Board expect tax to be paid throughout the year, not just when the return is filed.


That matters when income is not fully covered by withholding. Self-employment income, investment gains, rental income, retirement distributions, stock compensation, and business profits can all create underpayment penalties.


The good news: most penalties can be prevented with safe harbor planning. Some assessed penalties can also be reduced or removed if the facts support it.


This guide explains how to avoid IRS penalties and how to avoid california ftb penalties tied to estimated tax underpayments. It also explains what to do if the IRS or FTB has already assessed one.


This article is for general information only. Tax rules change, and the best answer depends on the full return, prior-year tax, current-year income, withholding, credits, and payment dates.


Eye-level view of a taxpayer marking estimated tax dates on a kitchen calendar
Estimated tax penalties usually start with missed payment timing, not just missed payment amounts.

Estimated tax penalties happen when tax is paid too late during the year


The IRS and FTB both use a pay-as-you-go system.


That means tax should be paid as income is earned. Wage withholding usually handles this for employees. Estimated tax payments handle it for people who have income without enough withholding.


Estimated tax penalties can apply even if the full balance is paid by April 15. The issue is timing.


Example:


  • A taxpayer owes $20,000 for the year.

  • Nothing is paid during the year.

  • The full $20,000 is paid with the return in April.


That taxpayer may still owe an underpayment penalty because the tax was not paid throughout the year.


The penalty is interest-like. It is calculated based on how much should have been paid for each required installment period and how late each payment was. The IRS uses federal underpayment rates. California uses its own interest rate system.


The penalty is separate from other charges, such as:


  • Failure-to-file penalties

  • Failure-to-pay penalties

  • Interest on unpaid tax

  • Accuracy-related penalties

  • California mandatory e-pay penalties


Estimated tax penalties are often smaller than those penalties, but they still add up. They also create notices, confusion, and time spent fixing preventable problems.


Who needs to make estimated tax payments


Estimated tax payments may be needed when withholding will not cover enough tax.


Common income sources that trigger estimated tax planning include:


  • Self-employment income

  • Independent contractor income

  • Partnership or S corporation income

  • Rental income

  • Capital gains

  • Dividends and interest

  • Cryptocurrency or digital asset gains

  • Pension or IRA distributions without enough withholding

  • Social Security benefits with taxable income

  • Unemployment compensation

  • Stock option or equity compensation income

  • Large bonuses with insufficient withholding


A person with wages can still need estimated tax payments. This happens when withholding is too low or other income increases the total tax bill.


A person without wages can often avoid estimates by using withholding from retirement distributions, if available. Withholding has a major advantage. For many penalty calculations, withholding is treated as paid evenly throughout the year, even if it happens later in the year. That can help fix a shortfall before year-end.


Estimated payments do not replace filing a tax return. They are prepayments. The return still reconciles the final tax, credits, payments, and refund or balance due.


IRS rules for avoiding federal underpayment penalties


The main IRS rules are found in IRS Form 1040-ES, Form 2210, and IRS guidance on underpayment of estimated tax by individuals.


For most individual taxpayers, the federal underpayment penalty can be avoided if one of these safe harbors is met.


The balance due is less than $1,000


No federal estimated tax penalty is generally due if the tax owed after subtracting withholding and refundable credits is less than $1,000.


This is why a small balance due on a return does not always create a penalty.


Example:


  • Total federal tax for the year is $14,500.

  • Withholding and credits are $13,700.

  • Balance due is $800.


The balance due is under $1,000, so the federal underpayment penalty generally does not apply.


This safe harbor is useful, but it is not a planning method for larger tax situations. A growing business, large capital gain, or big year-end distribution can push the balance well above $1,000 fast.


Payments equal at least 90% of the current-year tax


The IRS generally does not assess an estimated tax penalty if withholding and timely estimated payments equal at least 90% of the current-year tax.


Example:


  • Current-year federal tax is $40,000.

  • The taxpayer pays $36,000 during the year through withholding and estimated tax payments.

  • $36,000 is 90% of $40,000.


The taxpayer may still owe $4,000 with the return, but the 90% current-year safe harbor may prevent the federal underpayment penalty.


This method works well when income can be projected with reasonable accuracy. It can be harder for taxpayers with irregular income, stock sales, business income, or large year-end events.


Payments equal 100% of the prior-year tax


The IRS also allows a prior-year safe harbor for many taxpayers.


A taxpayer can generally avoid the federal underpayment penalty by paying at least 100% of the prior-year tax through withholding and timely estimated payments.


The prior-year return must cover a full 12-month year.


Example:


  • Last year’s federal tax was $30,000.

  • This year’s federal tax is $60,000.

  • The taxpayer pays $30,000 during the year.


Even though the taxpayer owes $30,000 with the return, the prior-year safe harbor may prevent the federal underpayment penalty.


This safe harbor is valuable when income rises during the year. It does not eliminate the tax due. It only helps prevent the estimated tax penalty.


High-income taxpayers may need to pay 110% of prior-year tax


The federal prior-year safe harbor increases for higher-income taxpayers.


If prior-year adjusted gross income was more than $150,000, or more than $75,000 if married filing separately, the taxpayer generally must pay 110% of the prior-year tax to use the federal prior-year safe harbor.


Example:


  • Prior-year AGI was $220,000.

  • Prior-year federal tax was $50,000.

  • The federal prior-year safe harbor is generally $55,000, which is 110% of $50,000.


Paying only $50,000 may not be enough.


This is one of the most common mistakes. People remember the 100% rule but miss the 110% rule.


No prior-year tax liability can provide an exception


The IRS generally does not assess the estimated tax penalty if the taxpayer had no tax liability for the prior year, was a U.S. citizen or resident for the whole year, and the prior tax year covered 12 months.


This rule can help after a low-income year, a year with large credits, or a year before a business becomes profitable.


Do not rely on this rule without checking the prior return. “No balance due” is not the same as “no tax liability.” A return can show no balance due because withholding covered the tax. That is different from having no tax liability.


Farmers and fishermen have special federal rules


Farmers and fishermen may qualify for special estimated tax rules. In general, if at least two-thirds of gross income comes from farming or fishing, a lower annual payment threshold may apply. There is also a special filing and payment option tied to early filing.


These rules are narrow. They require careful review of income sources and timing.


Most taxpayers should not use these rules unless farming or fishing income is clearly central to the return.


California FTB rules are similar, but not identical


California’s rules overlap with the federal rules, but they are not the same. That difference creates penalties for taxpayers who only plan for the IRS.


California estimated tax rules are addressed in FTB Form 540-ES and FTB Form 5805.


The FTB can assess a penalty when required estimated tax installments are not paid on time or are too low.


California has a smaller balance-due threshold


For California, individuals generally avoid the estimated tax penalty if the amount owed after subtracting withholding and credits is less than $500, or $250 if married filing separately or registered domestic partners filing separately.


This threshold is lower than the federal $1,000 threshold.


Example:


  • Federal balance due is $800.

  • California balance due is $800.


The federal penalty may not apply because the balance due is under $1,000. The California penalty may still apply because the California threshold is generally $500.


This is a common trap.


California generally allows a 90% current-year safe harbor


California generally allows taxpayers to avoid the underpayment penalty if payments and credits equal at least 90% of the current-year tax.


This rule is similar to the federal current-year safe harbor.


Example:


  • Current-year California tax is $18,000.

  • California withholding and timely estimated payments are $16,200.

  • $16,200 is 90% of $18,000.


The taxpayer may still owe $1,800 with the California return, but the 90% current-year safe harbor may protect against the estimated tax penalty.


California generally allows a 100% prior-year safe harbor


California generally allows a prior-year safe harbor if timely payments and credits equal 100% of the prior-year California tax, assuming the prior-year return covered 12 months.


This can help when current-year income rises.


Example:


  • Prior-year California tax was $12,000.

  • Current-year California tax is $25,000.

  • The taxpayer pays $12,000 during the year.


The taxpayer may owe $13,000 with the California return, but the California prior-year safe harbor may help avoid the estimated tax penalty.


California has a major high-income exception


California has a stricter rule for high-income taxpayers.


If California adjusted gross income is $1,000,000 or more, or $500,000 or more if married filing separately or registered domestic partners filing separately, the taxpayer generally cannot use the prior-year safe harbor. The taxpayer must generally pay based on the current year, usually using the 90% current-year rule.


This is a major difference from federal law.


Example:


  • Prior-year California tax was $80,000.

  • Current-year California tax is $250,000.

  • Current-year California AGI is over $1,000,000.


Paying 100% of last year’s California tax may not prevent a California estimated tax penalty. The taxpayer generally needs to pay based on current-year tax.


Anyone with large capital gains, business sale income, stock option income, or a high-profit year should check this rule before relying on last year’s tax.


California installment percentages differ from federal rules


Federal estimated tax payments are generally paid in four equal installments.


California uses a different installment pattern for many individual taxpayers:


Payment

Federal general pattern

California general pattern

1st installment

25%

30%

2nd installment

25%

40%

3rd installment

25%

0%

4th installment

25%

30%


This matters. A taxpayer can be current for federal purposes and still be short for California because California front-loads the first two payments.


California’s general estimated tax due dates match the familiar quarterly pattern for calendar-year taxpayers:


  • April 15

  • June 15

  • September 15

  • January 15 of the following year


Due dates can shift for weekends, holidays, disasters, and official postponements.


Do not assume California wants four equal payments. That mistake can create an FTB penalty even when the annual total is correct.


Close-up of handwritten federal and California estimated tax amounts beside a calculator
Federal and California payment schedules should be planned separately.

The best ways to prevent estimated tax penalties


The safest approach is to plan federal and California payments separately. The numbers often differ.


A person may owe federal tax but little California tax, or the reverse. California does not follow every federal rule, and California’s high-income safe harbor rule can change the answer.


Start with last year’s tax return


Last year’s return gives the fastest safe harbor estimate.


Find these amounts:


  • Prior-year total federal tax

  • Prior-year adjusted gross income

  • Prior-year California tax

  • Prior-year California adjusted gross income

  • Withholding expected for the current year

  • Refundable credits expected for the current year


Then ask these questions:


  • Was last year a full 12-month tax year?

  • Was there any prior-year tax liability?

  • Is the federal 110% rule triggered?

  • Is the California $1,000,000 AGI rule triggered?

  • Will current-year income be much higher or lower?

  • Will withholding cover enough tax?


This gives a baseline. It may not be perfect, but it can identify a safe harbor early.


Recalculate when income changes


One estimate in April may be wrong by September.


Recalculate after major events, such as:


  • Selling stock or real estate

  • Exercising stock options

  • Receiving a bonus

  • Starting or closing a business

  • Taking a large retirement distribution

  • Converting a retirement account

  • Receiving partnership or S corporation income

  • Losing or gaining a job

  • Moving into or out of California


The goal is not exact perfection. The goal is to avoid being short under the safe harbor rules.


Use withholding when possible


Withholding can be powerful because it is often treated as paid evenly throughout the year for penalty purposes.


This can help when a taxpayer discovers a shortfall late in the year.


Common withholding sources include:


  • Wages

  • Bonuses

  • Pension payments

  • IRA distributions

  • Certain retirement account distributions

  • Unemployment compensation, where available

  • Social Security benefits, if voluntary withholding is elected


Example:


  • A taxpayer realizes in November that estimated payments are short.

  • The taxpayer has wages or can take a taxable retirement distribution.

  • Extra withholding is made before year-end.


That withholding may help cover earlier underpayments in a way that a late estimated payment may not.


This strategy must be handled carefully. Retirement distributions can create more taxable income. Early distributions may create additional tax. The withholding should solve the underpayment problem without creating a bigger tax problem.


Pay each installment on time


Estimated tax payments are time-sensitive.


Paying the correct annual amount is not always enough. The IRS and FTB look at required installments by period.


For calendar-year taxpayers, the usual federal due dates are:


  • April 15

  • June 15

  • September 15

  • January 15 of the following year


California uses the same general due dates, but its installment percentages differ.


When a due date falls on a weekend or legal holiday, the deadline generally moves to the next business day. Disaster relief can also extend deadlines for affected taxpayers.


Late payments reduce the penalty from the payment date forward, but they do not erase the penalty for the period before payment.


Use the annualized income method for uneven income


Some taxpayers do not earn income evenly throughout the year.


That includes people who receive:


  • A large capital gain in December

  • Most business income in the fourth quarter

  • A bonus late in the year

  • Seasonal self-employment income

  • Real estate sale income in one quarter

  • Partnership or S corporation income reported unevenly


The regular penalty calculation may assume income was earned evenly. That can create an unfair penalty if the income was actually earned later.


The annualized income installment method can fix this.


For federal purposes, this is handled on Form 2210. For California, this is generally handled on Form 5805.


Example:


  • A taxpayer sells a rental property in November.

  • The gain creates most of the tax for the year.

  • Earlier estimated payments were low because the income had not happened yet.


The annualized method may reduce or eliminate the penalty by matching required payments to when the income was actually earned.


This method requires accurate period-by-period income records. Keep brokerage statements, closing statements, profit and loss reports, payroll records, and retirement distribution records.


Do not forget self-employment tax


Self-employed taxpayers often estimate income tax but forget self-employment tax.


Federal self-employment tax covers Social Security and Medicare taxes for self-employment income. It can be a large part of the total federal tax bill.


Estimated tax payments should cover:


  • Federal income tax

  • Self-employment tax

  • Additional Medicare Tax, if applicable

  • Net investment income tax, if applicable

  • California income tax

  • Any other applicable state taxes


California does not have a self-employment tax, but California income tax can still be significant.


Adjust for tax credits and deductions carefully


Credits and deductions affect estimated tax calculations.


Common items include:


  • Child tax credits

  • Education credits

  • Energy credits

  • Estimated business deductions

  • Retirement contributions

  • Health savings account contributions

  • Itemized deductions

  • Qualified business income deduction, if applicable for federal purposes

  • California adjustments and credits


Do not assume California matches the federal number. California has its own rules for many deductions, credits, and adjustments.


This is another reason to run separate federal and California projections.


Keep proof of every payment


Payment records matter when a penalty notice is wrong.


Keep:


  • Confirmation numbers

  • Bank records

  • Canceled checks, if used

  • Payment dates

  • Amounts paid

  • Tax year applied

  • Tax agency paid

  • Spouse name and Social Security number used, if filing jointly


Payment misapplication is common. A payment can be applied to the wrong tax year or the wrong spouse account. Clear proof makes the fix faster.


Common mistakes that trigger IRS and FTB penalties


Most estimated tax penalties come from a few preventable errors.


Relying on the federal rule for California


California has different thresholds, different installment percentages, and a high-income exception to the prior-year safe harbor.


A federal safe harbor does not automatically protect against an FTB penalty.


Paying four equal California installments


California’s general pattern is 30%, 40%, 0%, and 30%, not four equal 25% payments.


Four equal payments may leave the first and second California installments underpaid.


Missing the federal 110% prior-year rule


Higher-income taxpayers often need to pay 110% of prior-year federal tax, not 100%, to use the federal prior-year safe harbor.


The test is based on prior-year AGI.


Ignoring a large one-time income event


A stock sale, real estate sale, business sale, or large distribution can change the whole year.


Waiting until April to deal with it can create penalties.


Assuming a refund last year means no estimated payments this year


A refund only means payments exceeded tax last year. It does not mean current-year withholding is enough.


A taxpayer can receive a refund one year and owe penalties the next year if income changes.


Applying payments to the wrong year


This happens often near January deadlines.


The January estimated payment is usually for the prior tax year, not the new calendar year. Payment screens often require the taxpayer to select the tax year.


A wrong-year payment can create a penalty even when cash was sent on time.


Forgetting California after moving


California part-year residents may still have California filing and payment obligations. California-source income can also matter for nonresidents.


Moving does not automatically end California tax exposure for all income.


Residency and source rules are fact-specific. They need careful review.


What to do if the IRS assessed an estimated tax penalty


Do not ignore the notice.


Start by finding out whether the penalty is correct. IRS notices can be right, partly right, or wrong.


Step 1. Identify the notice and tax year


Look for:


  • Tax year

  • Penalty amount

  • Type of penalty

  • Payment history used by the IRS

  • Response deadline

  • Whether the IRS changed the return or only assessed a penalty


Estimated tax penalties often relate to Form 2210. Some returns calculate the penalty before filing. In other cases, the IRS calculates it later and sends a notice.


Step 2. Compare IRS records to your records


Check whether the IRS included all payments and withholding.


Look for:


  • Missing estimated payments

  • Payments applied to the wrong year

  • Payments applied to a spouse’s account

  • Incorrect withholding

  • Refund applied from a prior year but not credited

  • Amended return changes

  • Late-posted payments


If a payment is missing, provide proof. Use bank records and payment confirmations.


Step 3. Check safe harbor eligibility


Recalculate the penalty using the safe harbor rules.


Ask:


  • Was the balance due under $1,000?

  • Were total payments at least 90% of current-year tax?

  • Were payments enough under the prior-year safe harbor?

  • Did the 110% rule apply?

  • Was there no prior-year tax liability?

  • Was income earned unevenly during the year?

  • Was disaster relief available?


If the IRS did not have all facts, the penalty may be overstated.


Step 4. Consider filing or revising Form 2210


Form 2210 can show why a penalty should be reduced or waived.


It can be used to:


  • Apply the annualized income installment method

  • Report uneven income

  • Claim a waiver in certain situations

  • Show penalty exceptions

  • Correct the penalty calculation


A taxpayer does not always need to file Form 2210. But when the IRS assessed a penalty and the facts support a lower amount, Form 2210 can be key.


Step 5. Request a waiver if facts support it


The IRS can waive the underpayment penalty in limited situations.


Possible waiver grounds include:


  • Casualty

  • Disaster

  • Other unusual circumstances where applying the penalty would be unfair

  • Retirement after age 62 during the tax year or prior year, if the underpayment was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect

  • Disability during the tax year or prior year, if the underpayment was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect


A waiver request should be specific. Do not send a vague letter.


Include:


  • What happened

  • When it happened

  • How it affected the ability to pay estimates

  • What steps were taken to fix it

  • Supporting documents


The IRS does not remove penalties just because the taxpayer did not know the rule. Reasonable cause needs facts.


What to do if the California FTB assessed an estimated tax penalty


FTB notices should also be reviewed quickly.


California penalty notices often arise from missing payments, wrong installment timing, or failure to meet California’s own safe harbor rules.


Step 1. Confirm the FTB used the correct payments


Compare the FTB account transcript or notice to actual records.


Check:


  • California withholding

  • Estimated payments

  • Prior-year refund transfers

  • Payment dates

  • Tax year applied

  • Payment account used

  • Joint filer information


If a payment was misapplied, contact the FTB and provide proof.


Step 2. Check California safe harbors


Review these rules:


  • Was the balance due under $500, or under $250 for separate filers?

  • Were payments and credits at least 90% of current-year California tax?

  • Did the taxpayer qualify for the 100% prior-year California safe harbor?

  • Was California AGI high enough to block the prior-year safe harbor?

  • Were California installment percentages paid correctly?

  • Was income uneven during the year?


Do not assume the federal result controls. It does not.


Step 3. Use Form 5805 when needed


California Form 5805 is used for underpayment of estimated tax by individuals and fiduciaries.


It can help show:


  • The correct penalty amount

  • Whether an exception applies

  • Whether the annualized income method reduces the penalty

  • Whether the FTB calculation should be adjusted


For taxpayers with uneven income, Form 5805 can be as important as federal Form 2210.


Step 4. Request penalty relief if facts support it


California may reduce or waive penalties in certain cases, but the request must be supported. The FTB generally wants documentation and a clear explanation.


Possible facts may include disaster relief, serious events outside the taxpayer’s control, or other circumstances recognized under California procedures.


A successful request should be direct:


  • State the tax year and notice number.

  • Explain the penalty being disputed.

  • Identify the rule or exception.

  • Attach payment proof or forms.

  • Request a specific correction or waiver.


A practical estimated tax planning checklist


Use this checklist before each estimated tax deadline.


Federal review


  • Check projected federal tax for the year.

  • Check expected federal withholding.

  • Check estimated tax payments already made.

  • Compare payments to 90% of current-year tax.

  • Compare payments to 100% or 110% of prior-year tax.

  • Confirm whether the prior-year return covered 12 months.

  • Include self-employment tax, if applicable.

  • Consider annualized income if income is uneven.


California review


  • Check projected California tax.

  • Check expected California withholding.

  • Compare payments to 90% of current-year California tax.

  • Compare payments to 100% of prior-year California tax, if allowed.

  • Check whether California AGI may reach $1,000,000, or $500,000 for separate filers.

  • Use California’s 30%, 40%, 0%, and 30% installment pattern.

  • Consider Form 5805 if income is uneven.


Payment review


  • Confirm the payment tax year before submitting.

  • Save confirmation numbers.

  • Keep bank records.

  • Record payment dates.

  • Separate IRS and FTB payments.

  • Recheck projections after large income events.


Quick examples that show how the rules work


Example 1. Federal safe harbor works, but California penalty still applies


A taxpayer owes $800 to the IRS and $800 to California after withholding.


The IRS estimated tax penalty may not apply because the federal balance due is under $1,000.


California may still assess a penalty because California’s general threshold is $500, or $250 for separate filers.


Same balance. Different result.


Example 2. Prior-year federal safe harbor works for rising income


A taxpayer’s prior-year federal tax was $22,000. Current-year federal tax is $55,000. Prior-year AGI was below $150,000.


The taxpayer pays $22,000 during the year.


The taxpayer may owe $33,000 with the return. But the federal prior-year safe harbor may prevent the estimated tax penalty.


This does not mean the tax is reduced. It only means the penalty may be avoided.


Example 3. California high-income rule blocks the prior-year safe harbor


A taxpayer has a major business sale. California AGI exceeds $1,000,000.


Prior-year California tax was $40,000. Current-year California tax is $180,000.


Paying $40,000 may not protect against a California estimated tax penalty. The taxpayer generally needs to pay based on current-year California tax.


This is one of the most expensive California estimated tax traps.


Example 4. Annualized income method reduces the penalty


A taxpayer sells stock in December and has a large gain.


The IRS or FTB calculation assumes tax should have been paid earlier in the year. But the income did not exist earlier in the year.


Using Form 2210 for federal or Form 5805 for California may reduce the penalty by showing when the income was actually earned.


When to get help


Get help before the deadline if any of these apply:


  • Current-year income is much higher than last year.

  • California AGI may exceed $1,000,000, or $500,000 for separate filers.

  • A large capital gain occurred.

  • A business had a major profit increase.

  • The taxpayer moved into or out of California.

  • A notice has already been issued.

  • Payments may have been applied to the wrong year.

  • Income was uneven and the annualized method may help.

  • The penalty is large enough to fight.


Estimated tax penalties are technical. The forms look simple until income timing, safe harbors, withholding, credits, and California differences come into play.


A careful review can answer three questions:


  1. Was the penalty correct?

  2. Can it be reduced?

  3. Can future penalties be prevented?


Wide-angle view of a person organizing tax records at a dining table
Good records make penalty reviews faster and more accurate.

The bottom line


Estimated tax penalties are avoidable when payments are planned around the actual rules.


For the IRS, focus on the $1,000 threshold, the 90% current-year safe harbor, the 100% or 110% prior-year safe harbor, withholding, and Form 2210 when income is uneven.


For California, do not copy the federal plan without checking FTB rules. California has a lower balance-due threshold, front-loaded payment percentages, and a major high-income exception that can block the prior-year safe harbor.


If the IRS or California FTB has already assessed a penalty, review it before paying. Check the payments, safe harbors, income timing, and waiver options. Notices are not always final, and penalties are not always correct.


Contact information


Need help with an IRS or California FTB estimated tax penalty?


Contact our Irvine, California office for help reviewing the notice, checking the safe harbor rules, and determining whether the penalty can be reduced or removed. We assist taxpayers nationwide and in person by appointment in Irvine.

OC Tax CPA

1 Park Plaza #600 Irvine, CA 92614

(949) 572-7432


 
 
 

Comments


OC Tax CPA​

​

Office Address: 1 Park Plaza Suite 600 Irvine, CA 92614

Flag_of_the_United_States.svg.png

Call The Office

Office Hours

Mon - Sat 8am - 6pm

Sun: CLOSED

SERVICES

Tax Planning

Tax Preparation

Bookkeeping

Financial Statement Compilation

Payroll & Business Services

Business Formation

​

​

HELPFUL LINKS

bottom of page